Why Your Training Manual Is Failing You — and How to Fix It

Your detailed procedures might be doing more harm than good.
When pressure hits, staff freeze or make poor choices because they can’t sort through every step in time.
What they need isn’t more direction — it’s clearer intent.

Most childcare incidents don’t happen because staff don’t care.
They happen because staff don’t understand what really matters in the moment.

You review policies. You post reminders. You hold trainings.
Then something goes wrong and you hear:

“I didn’t know.”
“I wasn’t told that.”
“I didn’t think I could.”

If you haven’t heard this, congratulations — you probably don’t need to read this article.

For the rest of us, these responses aren’t rebellion. They’re the result of information overload that prevents staff from thinking for themselves.

When staff try to remember every rule, they lose sight of the reason behind them.
And when they lose the reason, they lose clarity — the thing that keeps kids safe.

What the Military Learned

The military faces constant chaos — broken communication, failed plans, and fast-changing conditions.
In battle, there may be mountains of information that support the mission, but ensuring every soldier retains all of it in real time is impossible.

To keep teams aligned, commanders began using something called Commander’s Intent — a short statement that defines the mission’s purpose and desired end state.

It answers three questions:

1. What are we trying to achieve?
2. Why does it matter?
3. What does success look like?

When people know those answers, they can adapt on their own and still accomplish the goal — even when the plan falls apart.

How “Director’s Intent” Fits Childcare

You can’t predict every situation in childcare, but you can make sure your team knows what matters most.
That’s where Director’s Intent (or Center's Intent...you can call it what works for you) comes in.

Think of it as a clear purpose behind every procedure — a compass, not a checklist.‍

A Quick Story

At one of my centers, we stationed a staff member at the drinking fountain during outdoor play.
We’d had issues there before — children playing in or around the water — so the staff’s job was to prevent that.

One day, two children raced toward the fountain.
The staff member stood nearby. As the children neared the water and slippery ground, one slipped, hit their head, and cried.

After caring for the child and notifying the parent, I asked the staff why they didn’t stop the running.
The answer came quickly:

“I was never told what to do if that happened.”

The staff knew where to stand but didn’t understand why they were there.

Now, apply Director’s Intent:

1. What are we trying to achieve?
Keep children safe and prevent injuries near the fountain.

2. Why does it matter?
For the child’s safety first — and for the trust the parent places in us.

3. What does success look like?
Children get water safely.
No running. No rough play. No injuries.

Once the staff knows that’s the goal, they act.
If a child runs, they step in — not because they memorized a rule, but because it breaks the intent.

How to Start Using Director’s Intent

Stop adding more procedures.
Start creating more clarity.

Step 1: Define the “Why”

Pick three to five problem areas — playground, transitions, naptime, or pickup.
Look at each procedure and strip it down to the reason it exists.
Write one sentence that defines the desired outcome.

Example:

• ‍‍Weak: “Stand between cones 1 and 2 during pickup.”
• Strong: “Make sure each child leaves safely with the correct adult and no child is left behind.”

Step 2: Train the Intent, Not Just the Task

At your next meeting, lead with purpose before procedure.
Ask:

“If the plan breaks — the walkie dies, the alarm sounds, the routine shifts — how will you still meet the intent?”

When staff train this way, they start thinking instead of reacting.

Step 3: Measure by Intent, Not Compliance

After an incident, skip “Did you follow the rule?”
Ask:

“Did we meet the Director’s Intent?”

This shifts the focus from blame to accountability.
It honors good judgment — even if a small rule was bent for safety.

The Takeaway

Procedures help.
Purpose protects.

Director’s Intent keeps your team grounded when things go wrong.

When everyone knows why they’re there and what success looks like, they make better calls — fast, confident, and focused on safety.

“Strong directors don’t manage rules. They lead with clarity.”

Start defining your Director’s Intent today — and watch your team’s confidence grow.

‍